Saturday, September 24, 2011
Standards, Standards Everywhere
First of all I made the mistake of printing off all three standards so that I could do a side-by-side comparison. Even with printing out only my assigned standards, I still had over thirty pieces of paper to compare. This made things a little confusing! The first thing I noticed was that the NCTM standards had a “data analysis and probability “ standard, the Common Core (CC) had a “statistics and probability” standard and the CMP also had a “data analysis and probability “ standard. This meant that none of the CMP and NCTM standards directly aligned with the CC standards. The second thing I noticed was that the NCTM had standards that covered several grades (3-5, 6-8, and 9-12) while the CC had separate standards for each grade level 6th, 7th, and 8th and then a high school standard. Meanwhile the CMP listed the standards and then wrote the grade level beside the standard (6th, 7th, or 8th or a combination of the three). The way these standards were set up made it confusing ad near impossible to compare. In the end I did find similarities amongst the standards, but I could not find two standards from different organizations that completely matched up. As a new teacher, I'm not sure how I'd create a lesson plan that completely conforms to all three standards.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
These were overwhelming and confusing to me, also, at first. But as one steps back and looks at the big picture, the view changes. Most candidates found the standards to align after they stepped back. In general, the CC (national) are big-picture guidelines. Whether they are by individual grade (6,7,8) or lumped together, shouldn't matter. Look at the big picture.
ReplyDeleteThe NCTM standards have been around for decades, and thus dig deeper into each area. If you work from these sets of standards, I think you'll find the align under the big-picture (CC) and down in to the CPM (which is just one strategy for chunking and implementing the standards. Jargon varies, but the more you peruse through these 3 sets of standards but more you'll see how they align.
Confusing. INDEED. FRUSTRATING, INDEED. Hang in there :)